Wired vs Wireless dog fence: Which type is the best for your dog? The above question is what every dog owner asks whenever they want to confine their best four-legged friend in a safe place. Using a leash is the only option for people living in the city where yards and parks are shared; however, this is different for people with their yards. You can consider using a wooden or chain fence.
If you have some vegetables or want to restrict your dog from accessing some areas of the yard, you must partition the dog area using a wired or wireless dog fence.
Today, you can spend a few dollars to purchase the best wireless dog fence, unlike when people used to build walls.
Mainly widely used dog fences are wireless pet fences and wired in-ground or underground dog fences. To make the right decision, you need to compare between the two. Below is a detailed comparison of wireless vs. wired dog fence systems.
Factors to consider when purchasing dog fence
Types of collars
Wireless fence collars
- They are heavier than wired collars.
- Have two pairs of contact points for long and shorthaired dogs.
- The collars have different stimulation levels up to five.
- Different training modes.
Wired fence collars
- Wired fence collars are lighter.
- They come with one pair of contact points.
- It has no variable static shock stimulation levels.
Purchasing cost
Quality wireless fences, such as Extreme Dog or Pet Safe Wireless, will cost you less than $200.If you need to contain more dogs in the system, you must purchase more collars. You will also spend more on buying batteries.
Wired fences will cost you almost the same amount, but you will not incur more cost of purchasing extra dog collars or replaceable lithium batteries. Therefore, wired fences are cheaper in terms of purchasing cost compared to two-wired vs. wireless dog fences.
Installation cost and ease
Wireless dog fences are easy to install and require no cost. They are DIY; you can set them anywhere, even in a public park or yard. It’s not the same for wired dog fences. If you prefer burying the wired fence in the ground so it is not damaged, you will incur the extra cost of paying people to dig the trenches. The cost will vary depending on the place where you live.
Portability
Wireless dog fences are the best if you are looking for a portable dog fence that can be carried anywhere. They are light, and you can take them inside your bag. Consider purchasing a wired fence if you have a permanent resident with a backyard.
Maintenance cost
Maintaining a wireless fence system is cheaper. If the collar or receiver has problems, repairing is a few dollars. In addition, some of the best dog training collars come with a one-year warranty and 24/7 custom service support. I recommend that my readers buy Sport Dog collars because they are versatile and easy for puppy or gun dog training.
A small problem with a wired dog fence may require you to dig the whole wire and replace it with a new one because tracing the place with a problem can be challenging.
Signal strength
Signal strength and interference can be a problem when using wireless dog fences. Several wireless fences in the same surroundings can interfere with each other because their frequency will overlap. The error margin in a wireless fence system is 0.5 to 2 for a 200-diameter area.
The wired pet fence error margin for the boundary is around 0.25%. There is no signal interference if you install wired underground dog fences.
Containment area
Pet owners who do not know wireless pet fences search for rectangle or wireless dog fences in rectangular yards when they want to make a purchase. They must learn that most wireless fence systems cover circular areas up to 250 feet, depending on the mode. However, you can cover more area and create any shape using extra transmitters. For example, you can combine two or more transmitters using pet-safe wireless fence systems.
A wired in-ground pet fence or wired underground pet fence can cover any large area and can be made to take the shape of your yard or land. The wired dog fence is best for covering a large area. Therefore, comparing wired vs. wireless dog fences in terms of the area contained, a wired pet fence is the best for large yards.
Featured dog fence reviews
It would be unfair if I did not review at least one of the best wireless fences for dogs and one of the best-wired fences for dogs.
Best wireless dog fence
We considered a dog fence with gaps when choosing the best wireless one. GPS capability allows tracking your dog’s location in the containment area. Below is our pick for the best GPS wireless dog fence.
Dog Expedition Patrol GPS System -Best GPS wireless dog fence
Dog Expedition Patrol GPS System Key Features
- It is perfect for dog owners who want to track their location in a containment system.
- It is a portable system and 100 % wireless.
- The fence operating range is up to 800 yards.
- It is best for use at the camp, home, park, or trips to any place.
- The Dog Expedition Patrol GPS also has abilities for remote training your dog.
- It’s the best GPS wireless dog fence because it gives peace of mind, and your dog is free to roam.
Best-wired dog fence
Our pick for the best-wired dog fence is-
Sport DOG In-Ground Fence System
Key Features in SportDog In-ground dog fence
- It has different levels of shock stimulation up to four.
- There are two training modes, i.e., tone and vibration.
- It can cover up to 1 1/3 acres, including wire and flags.
- The fence system is expandable up to 100 acres.
- The collar receiver is 100% water-resistant.
- You can include any number of dogs if you buy extra collar receivers.
- It has an Anti-linger feature.
Related Questions
Here are questions related to the wired vs wireless dog fence topic.
How effective are wireless dog fences?
Every pet owner who loves their pooch must ask this important question before buying a wireless dog fence. Statistics show that wireless dog fences are 70% effective. Some people argue that invisible electric dog fences have visible effects on the dog. It makes the dog more aggressive because of the shock.
In addition, an electric wireless dog fence does not prevent other animals from invading the containment area. They cannot be used to confine dogs under six months. The transmitter also does not have lightning protection. Therefore, it is risky to operate in a rainy season.
Despite their drawbacks, a wireless dog fence has their advantages. First, they are portable and easy to set up.
In conclusion, how effective a wireless dog fence can be depends on how you will use the system. Depending on your needs, a wireless fence can be effective or ineffective.
What is the best wireless dog fence?
There are several types of wireless dog fences. Depending on your needs and budget, you have several options; therefore, you must do a checklist to pick the best wireless dog fence. For example,
Choosing the best wireless dog fence guiding factors
- Number of transmitters supported.
- Wireless dog fence range.
- Correction levels.
- Training options.
- Number of dogs the system can contain.
Do wireless dog fences work on hills?
The answer is yes.
Wireless dog fences can work in any terrain. All you need to do is adjust the transmitter position, and the system will work fine.
Conclusion
Your choice between wired vs wireless dog fences should be factor-driven. Pick the system that best suits your needs. Also, remember that your dog’s safety and comfort are paramount, so we take time to review the best dog products. Here are some other review posts.